Overboard in Dangerous Seas - A case study

Some time ago, we asked our LinkedIn community about the kind of things they would like to read about with regard to medical care at sea. One comment suggested some scene management around coping with casualty positioning in adverse weather. So, we got in touch for a chat and rather than settle for a generic article, we asked for a scenario to work with! This is what we got…

‘You are on an offshore installation with a man overboard incident, involving a 25m fall and some contact with structure. An Emergency Response Rescue Vessel (standby vessel) in close standby launches a Fast Rescue Craft. The FRC is alongside the casualty and the casualty recovered in 9 minutes with the FRC delivering your casualty onboard in 14 minutes.


The casualty is suffering from the cold, immersion,  and has a deep laceration to their forearm. The sea state is 3m, with a force 4 wind, sea temperature of 12 degrees, and air temperature of 10 degrees. The casualty must be transferred from the FRC to the boat deck. There is the possibility of transferring directly ashore to meet an ambulance to go to a hospital. All standard ERRV equipment is available. The FRC crew have applied direct pressure to the wound but no other treatment. As the ship is manoeuvring out of the platform exclusion zone there is a lot of rolling and you’re on an open steel deck.’


On further investigation you discover some additional information about what the crew member was wearing and an update on his condition. So let’s summarise the main points that will affect your medical response:


  • You have a casualty with a deep laceration to his forearm that is currently having direct pressure applied to it by one of the rescue crew.
  • He spent 9 minutes in the water which was 12 degrees Celsius and he was wearing a boiler suit. Air temperature was 10 degrees with a force 4 wind (13-18mph).
  • He had a lifejacket on and it was deployed, but because of his injured arm he couldn’t get the spray hood in position.
  • The casualty needs transferring from the FRC to the boat deck of the ERRV which is an open steel deck but there is a possibility the casualty can be transferred to the hospital.
  • The casualty appears to be deteriorating as he is now drifting in and out of consciousness.


Ouch, I hear you say! This one’s a tricky situation for sure. And it’s becoming more critical by the minute. So where do your priorities lie? How can we manage a ‘big sick’ casualty and make the right decision, in rough weather, as safely as possible?


We can prioritise. Thinking about the list we made above, we can change it round and set out priorities out:

  • The casualty needs transferring from the FRC to the boat deck of the ERRV which is an open steel deck but there is a possibility the casualty can be transferred to the hospital.
  • The casualty has a deep laceration to his forearm that is currently having direct pressure applied to it by one of the rescue crew. However, the casualty is deteriorating and is drifting in and out of consciousness.
  • He spent 9 minutes in the water which was 12 degrees Celsius and he was wearing a boiler suit. Air temperature was 10 degrees with a force 4 wind (13-18mph).
  • He had a lifejacket on and it was deployed, but because of his injured arm he couldn’t get the spray hood in position.


Next you need to break down each part of this huge dilemma. Remember… when eating big elephants, take small bites! Or simply, break down the points into bite sized chunks that can be managed. 


  • The casualty needs transferring from the FRC to the boat deck of the ERRV which is an open steel deck but there is a possibility the casualty can be transferred to the hospital.


Many ERRV’s have a basket style stretcher available which is a useful way of transferring a casualty from the FRC via the boat deck of the ERRV and then onwards to the hospital. They have a strap system that will allow you to keep the casualty safe during a transfer when the adverse weather makes it hard. This will require a team effort and all team members should be familiar with the use of the stretchers on board.

The casualty has a deep laceration to his forearm that is currently having direct pressure applied to it by one of the rescue crew. However, the casualty is deteriorating and is drifting in and out of consciousness.


How long should you apply direct pressure to the wound? What will affect the blood's ability to clot? So, we normally expect 10 minutes of direct pressure to control most bleeds of this nature but the casualty has been in the water and it was pretty cold! Hypothermia can affect the blood's ability to form a clot so the pressure may need to be held for an extended period of time with thought being given to clotting agents if they are available.


Based on the fact that the casualty is deteriorating, and their conscious level is dropping then we must go back to the beginning of our primary survey and start again. Do you remember what DRS CABC stand for? If you don’t then you need some refresher training ASAP!!

Danger – they have been removed to a place of safety but the ERRV is rolling heavily. Lets make sure that they are well secured in the stretcher and that we have plenty of people to help us manage the manual handling element of the rescue and get them into the hospital.


Response – they are drifting in and out of consciousness. What is our concern with this? If you answered with protecting the airway, then you are on the right path. With decreasing levels of consciousness, the risk of the airway becoming blocked becomes much higher. So, what should we do about this? We could use the recovery position, but we have equipment available to maintain the airway such as suction for fluids and oropharyngeal airways to keep the tongue clear of the airway.


Shout for help – well, you are the help so good luck with that!


Catastrophic Bleeds - these are dealt with as a priority as they are a life threatening injury.


Airway – As mentioned above this is at risk, so basic measures must be taken to maintain the airway as tolerated by the casualty. We could also consider the possibility of Cervical Spine injury at this point, this is based on the mechanism of injury – a whole other articles worth of info needed for that one!


Breathing – well we know that they are breathing but how effectively are they breathing? A basic look, listen and feel along with pulse oximetry will give us a better idea of the casualties breathing efforts. So, let's say that they have a breathing rate of 15, both sides of the chest are rising and falling evenly but the Pulse oximeter is reading 92%. What next? Do we put them on Oxygen? If so, how much? There are various systems available for delivering oxygen to a casualty. We always try to titrate to need so we would start off low using a venturi 24% mask set at 2 litres per minute and up it if necessary until we can achieve oxygen saturation levels above 95%. However, there is an important factor in the information that we have been given. Any idea what it might be? Yes! He was in the water and couldn’t deploy his splash hood. That increases his risk factor for complications from drowning. That will need close monitoring to ensure that his breathing does not deteriorate.


Circulation – So, this person has a deep laceration. Direct pressure is being applied but is that the only source of his bleeding? We know that there was some impact with the vessel when he fell overboard. What assessments should we be doing to work out how hard his heart is having to work? The best place to start is with a pulse. This can be taken at the neck or wrist and should be felt for 30 seconds. Times the result by 2 to get the beats per minute. So, our chap has a pulse of 96. A little high. We should also have assessed the strength and regularity and made a note of any abnormalities. We can do a capillary refill check on all 4 extremities. This will tell us if there is any compromise in the supply of blood to the furthest points in the body. If you are able then you can also do a blood pressure but this is not essential so please don’t worry if you don’t know how to do it.

The casualty is losing blood through his deep laceration but as he was a man overboard, he may well have injured other parts of his body and could even be bleeding internally. The organs of the abdomen, the pelvis and the femurs (thigh bones) are all places that blood can be lost in significant quantities so ensure that you check those thoroughly.


Next…..

I am going to throw in a couple of extra letters for your DRSABC algorithm. Just to keep you on your toes. DE. Arghhhhh….but that is just following the alphabet I hear you say! Well yes, us medics are a simple bunch really and need things to be easy to remember in an emergency. ABCDE is learnt as a child so what better way to remember how to assess our casualty?? So….


Disability – our casualty is drifting in and out of consciousness. He could possibly have a head injury so we ought to check that out. Remember how to check the pupils and what they are supposed to do? Right, well let's do that. His pupils are equal and reacting to light. Is that a good sign? Yes, it is…..for now. We need to check that regularly along with the ABC to make sure we don’t miss a significant change.

He spent 9 minutes in the water which was 12 degrees Celsius and he was wearing a boiler suit. Air temperature was 10 degrees with a force 4 wind (13-18mph). He had a lifejacket on and it was deployed, but because of his injured arm he couldn’t get the spray hood in position.


This leads us onto the final letter in our now extended primary survey. E.


Exposure – The body is designed to operate at between 36 – 37 degrees Celsius. Check out the temperature of the water, air and the wind speed. Combine that with what he was wearing and we are looking at many potential problems. But guess what? Cold shock would’ve got to him way before hypothermia sets in. Familiar with the effects of cold shock? I hope so because that is a whole other article!!


So, let’s take a temperature. Want an accurate one? Go rectal. Not concerned about hypothermia then oral or aural will suffice.

What about these wet clothes? He will continue to lose heat if left in them so lets cut them off and wrap layers of blankets around him. Whilst doing that check his whole body from top to toe for any further deformities, obvious injuries, tender areas or swelling and skin rashes.

Phew! Now what? You are not going to like me for this but…..


Start all over again and recheck your DRSCABCDE’s. Write notes, communicate significant information, recheck all vital signs and most importantly? Keep talking to the casualty. Be reassuring and calm (even if you don’t feel it), don’t discuss your fears in front of them, save that for out of earshot and mostly take comfort in knowing that you are doing your best in a pretty tough environment.


Everyone loves a case study....go on share it, you know it makes sense!


How about signing up for some of our free resources. If you enjoyed this then you will love Salt Water Solutions - a free training resource for you and your crew.


Worse Things Happen at Sea comes through mid monthly with more of a high level overview of what is going on within the industry with regards to the provision of First Aid and Medical Care.


Click on the images below to sign up.

by Rachel Smith 18 December 2024
Welcome to our December blog, which is all about the recovery position and how to manage an unconscious casualty who is breathing normally. Unconsciousness is a medical emergency as the person is very vulnerable and may not be able to manage their own airway effectively. We also need to think about the cause of unconsciousness. Is it a simple fainting episode due to illness? Is it a massive hemorrhage causing hypovolemic shock? Or is it due to some kind of external factor or injury? This blog looks at how to manage an unconscious casualty. So, if we have a casualty who is unconscious, but who is breathing normally for themselves, and we’re not suspecting a serious injury, the recovery position is the best position to use while monitoring them. The recovery position keeps their airway open and makes sure that vomit or liquid won’t cause them to choke.
by Rachel Smith 11 December 2024
All the guest blogs! When we started adding blogs to our website back in early 2021, we did a little feature on each of our instructors of the time. They’re quite a fascinating bunch and the series proved quite popular amongst our followers. In addition to our amazing instructors, we work with some utterly incredible human beings all over the world, and the idea of sharing their stories grew and developed into what eventually became a monthly guest blog. It’s been interesting to find out more about how medical care at sea or in remote locations features in their work, and to discover a few fun facts along the way. This month, we thought that it might be a fun idea to give you a chance to go back into the archives and review all the guest blogs over the last few years! Maybe even let us know which your favourite one is?
by Rachel Smith 27 November 2024
We’ve taken a look at the 2023 Casualty Summary Report from the Maritime Authority of the Cayman Islands (MACI) to see what kind of incidents and trends their data shows us, even with relatively small data sets, and how this may be able to transfer to our own risk assessments and actual practice. You can find the report here: Cayman Maritime Report 2023 The first thing we noted was the authors note that the data is split out into incidents. This means that one incident may include a number of events. So a collision and any resulting injury is one incident, but is reported as two events, or more, if more than one person is injured. It made us wonder whether this method of reporting by an authority represents how incidents are reported onboard and whether it should be a consideration? Of course, for any set of statistics presented at the moment, we also have to consider the COVID-19 pandemic and the impact this has on trends including that period. While essential shipping continued, the cruise and superyacht sectors reduced activity and staffing, often to a skeleton crew while anchored somewhere. So this will be reflected in the historic data sets that we analyse from 2019 to 2021 and may not accurately reflect increases and decreases during and since then. In some situations, we may need to look further back for accurate data. We also need to consider whether increases in incidents and events is also down to increased reporting - suggesting an improvement in the awareness of reporting requirements and greater engagement from the industry and individual sectors - this can only be a good development. Since 2020, the type of injury has been recorded in 8 different categories, with hand and foot injuries topping the leaderboard, closely followed by head, body, and back injuries. So if you were looking to run drills, or practise medical skills, these would be the key areas to cover. Only one death was an occupational accident, and is being investigated here: MAIB Investigations (search for case #9229607). It relates to a fall down a ventilation shaft on a bulk carrier in a Greek shipyard. The full report was still pending at the time of writing. Merchant ships are heavily regulated by a number of authorities, and the requirements for personal protective equipment and safe systems of work are enforced and applied to reduce accidents and incidents onboard. This has led to a lower reporting of incidents than in the commercial yacht sector. Could there be room for improvement here in this area? We certainly think so. Many of the hand and foot injuries reported can be career ending or life changing, but are preventable. Follow up has shown that there is a link here with injuries being sustained when inappropriate or no PPE was used. The supply and use of appropriate PPE is mandatory on vessels subject to the MLC and it’s worth remembering that some PPE can be produced in styles and designs compatible with the aesthetics of a yacht if required! On a much wider scale, a lack of transparency and standardisation globally can affect the collection of data and the issue of under reporting. While the MACI figures may be accurate, we need other accurate figures to compare them to, in order to build a bigger picture across the world as we have in aviation. From December 2024, the Maritime Labour Convention (MLC) will be enforcing an amendment so that seafarer deaths will be recorded and reported annually. The MACI and Cayman Islands Shipping Registry produces a number of safety flyers that are publicly available HERE that may be useful. In summary, analysing data can sometimes result in more questions than answers. But even this can lead to interesting and important developments that result in improved safety and reduced incidents and accidents onboard. Key points to take from this report are: Use the correct PPE for the task. Employ approved systems of work and risk assessments for the task. Reporting is key for safety in the future of our industry. Enjoy a night ashore, but don’t over do the cocktails! As always, if you’d like any input on medical training onboard or ashore, or drills that you can run yourselves, please just get in touch. References: https://www.lloydslist.com/LL1145359/Increase-in-incidents-of-deaths-at-sea
by Rachel Smith 6 November 2024
Welcome to our latest guest blog where we’ve been chatting to James Griffiths, General Manager of Ocean Operations for Scenic Group and finding out more about what happens behind the scenes in order to keep a fleet of luxury expedition ships running. Here’s what James told us… As General Manager of Ocean Operations, I’m responsible for the operations of our fleet which includes four ships in service with around 850 colleagues. I currently live in Mumbles, near Swansea in the UK, but due to the nature of my work I spend a significant amount of time living in Croatia. Prior to this role, I spent many years working at sea and worked up through the ranks to Captain and over the last 15 years, my main focus has been on polar expedition travel. I hold a master mariner certificate of competency in addition to a degree in engineering and a post graduate diploma in law. Part of my job is to work with our medical service provider (Red Square Medical) to ensure that our ships are offering medical services that are appropriate for their deployment, and this can often be to some of the most extreme and remote locations around the world. It’s extremely varied, though during the COVID-19 pandemic, I came ashore when our operations paused for a significant period of time. I was fortunate enough to be given the opportunity to lead the restart of our Ocean Operations, which included setting up everything from a company to manage the ships, to selecting our crewing, medical, helicopter and submarine partners and providers, amongst many other things. Our areas of operation, and the nature of our cruises (expedition), plus having aircraft and submersibles onboard some, do mean additional elements involved in the management of these ships. You could say that this current position is more of a happy coincidence than one that I actually planned for! In some ways this is a great positive - I do think it’s possible to plan a little too much and then be disappointed if things don’t go quite the way you had imagined. But there’s no danger of that here!
by Rachel Smith 3 October 2024
Back in February 2022, we brought you one of our very first guest blogs from Simon Lawton, a Paramedic who has swapped out his ambulance for a Superyacht! You can read the original blog here: https://www.redsquaremedical.com/superyacht-paramedic-a-guest-blog-from-simon-lawton Over the last 2+ years, we’ve followed Simon’s career, and some of you may even recognise him as he does put a Red Square Medical instructor hat on from time to time. But, as for all healthcare professionals, Simon has to keep his skills up to date. So, we asked him to tell us a bit more about how he juggles this along with a rota onboard. Here’s what he told us… I’m originally from Stoke-on-Trent in the UK and trained as a HCPC registered Paramedic. I’ve spent almost 5 years working at sea now, with almost continuous employment on three different vessels, after leaving the ambulance service in 2019. My first role was as a Paramedic/Deck hand on Superyachts, and I now work as a Medical Officer on a maritime vessel. Even before I applied to become a Paramedic, I intended to complete my studies to help find employment in a remote or offshore environment. I had always been attracted to the idea of being able to travel the world while earning a salary. Working at sea has meant that I have travelled extensively, earnt a higher salary, and have a better work/rest balance than would be possible in a role on land. Note: At the time of writing, a qualified Paramedic’s starting pay in the UK was £28,407 and Simon’s old rota was 2 days, 2 nights (all 12 hours) and 4 days off with very inflexible annual leave. This year I decided to carry out some continual professional development (CPD) at a hospital in Mexico, to keep my skills up to date. I was interested in travelling to find out more about how healthcare services are provided outside the UK and Europe. The CPD activity in Mexico allowed me to do exactly that, while caring for and treating a wide variety of patients who had either self-presented in the emergency department, or been conveyed to hospital by ambulance.
by Rachel Smith 25 September 2024
Welcome to our September blog, and as we all start (in the UK at least!) to think about adding a few layers for warmth, we’d like to talk about getting naked! Well, to be more specific, getting bra’s off. Fact: Women are dying because bystanders are less likely to carry out CPR on women than men. Research shows that women are 27% less likely to receive CPR than men and if a defibrillator is used, their chance of survival is affected by bra’s being left on. Most of us have never had the chance to train using a female manikin. The #BraOffDefibOn campaign aims to address the inequality in CPR for women and we’re supporting it.
by Rachel Smith 4 September 2024
In August, we brought you a Guest Blog from Mark Hannaford, the founder of World Extreme Medicine. This month, it’s the turn of another of the key WEM faculty members… introducing Dr Will Duffin. Hello everyone, I’m Dr Will Duffin and I’m a GP in Devon in the UK. I’m the Joint Medical Director of World Extreme Medicine (WEM) and the Lead Medic for the US CBS TV show ‘Survivor’ - for Seasons 43, 44, 46 and 48, which is also through WEM. Extreme Medicine is healthcare that is delivered across the full spectrum of remote, austere and challenging environments. This includes high mountains, deep oceans, jungles, deserts, polar, low earth orbit and refugee camps… the list is endless. Being a part of the wider Extreme Medicine community through WEM has been a portal into new worlds of possibility and opportunity in my medical career as an NHS GP. It’s a huge privilege to treat patients in a remote setting. You get to do proper ‘hands on’ medicine that truly tests your clinical skills, risk management and decision making. Even basic techniques and principles done well can transform patient outcomes. That’s the big reward. I graduated from Bristol Medical School in 2008 and completed my GP Training in Cornwall, UK in 2016. In between, I spent 18 months in Australia to gain as much emergency department experience as I could, whilst doing Wilderness Medicine Courses. I landed my first expedition gig 12 years ago when I was post-FY2 (Foundation Years follow on after qualifying as a doctor). I covered a Kilimanjaro Trek after another doctor dropped out at the last minute. Once I had this under my belt, I was able to leverage this experience to get the next trip. So, I soon found myself providing regular medical cover for various commercial and charity sector expeditions. These expeditions have taken me all over the world: Kilimanjaro, the Peruvian Andes, the Himalayas, Northern China, Eastern Europe, Myanmar and Madagascar. One highlight was working as the private doctor for a Luxury Trans-Siberian Train! Though I became frustrated having to constantly wrangle annual leave to go away, so I made the switch to being a freelance (locum) GP, which has given me the flexibility I need. I joined WEM in 2018 after responding to a Facebook Ad for the ‘Survivor’ job. I was invited to a selection weekend in the Peak District, which is when I first met Mark Hannaford WEM founder and CEO and Dr Joe Rowles, WEM’s other Medical Director, and it all went on from there. Early on, I was given the opportunity to lead on the content for the annual World Extreme Medicine Conference and our various podcasts and webinars. Through doing this, I have met a colourful cast of characters; other extreme medics who are as audacious as they are inspirational! We have a lot of fun at the conference every year, learning from one another. https://worldextrememedicine.com/registration/wem-conference-2024 (Note from the RSM team – the conference is highly recommended and well worth a visit!)
by Rachel Smith 5 August 2024
Last year, the Red Square Medical team descended on the World Extreme Medicine (WEM) conference for the very first time. We’d been aware of this unique organisation for many years, but just not had the chance to get involved. Liz was involved in a panel discussion and spoke at the conference, and we came away literally buzzing with enthusiasm - our first impressions were that WEM is a place with no ego’s, where everyone wants to learn, and is willing to share. We met some of the most fascinating people ever and can’t wait to go back this year. But what about the person who started it all… We spoke to Mark Hannaford, founder of World Extreme Medicine and its far reaching impact. Here’s what he had to say. I’ve been involved in expeditions, working in low resource environments and extreme medicine for the past three decades! My family was made up of generations of seafarers from Cornwall although I was brought up variously in Devon, Antigua in the Caribbean and the Middle East; reflecting my father’s job as a Master Mariner. My father was at one time the youngest captain aboard the UK’s largest registered vessel, and my grandfather was Harbour Master for Malta and the first in that role in Plymouth at the start of Queen Elizabeth’s reign. I wear a number of hats but primarily I am the founder and CEO of World Extreme Medicine, and the annual WEM Conference. I also founded the MSc in Extreme Medicine at the University of Exeter and Graduate Certificate program at Bouvré College of Health Sciences, Northeastern University, Boston.
by Rachel Smith 3 July 2024
Women’s health is a huge topic, while it’s true that in the maritime sector women make up just 2% of seafarers at sea, up to 34% of the shore based staff are female. Looking at the bigger picture, women’s health directly affects just under half of our population globally, and indirectly (whether you like it or not!) the other half, we thought it was worth a blog about some of the issues, and the taboo’s, that could be affecting our maritime workforce and the women in our lives. It's common knowledge that women experience huge hormonal changes at puberty and menopause, both of which can have significant physical and mental health impacts. In the UK, there is a growing discussion and openness about peri-menopause (the years before periods stop altogether) and how for some women, this has devastating effects across all aspects of their lives, including work. Of course men experience changes at puberty, but their later life changes are less significant and generally don’t affect their ability to work. In December 2023 the World Health Organisation (WHO) issued a statement to advise that every year, at least 40 million women are likely to experience a long term health problem caused by childbirth. So there’s a good chance that we all know one or more women affected, or if you are female… this could be you. As part of a special series on maternal health, the study showed a high burden of postnatal conditions that persist in the months and years after giving birth. These issues include more than a third of women experiencing pain during intercourse, urinary incontinence (8-31%), anal incontinence (19%), anxiety (9-24%), depression (11-17%), perineal pain (11%), a fear of childbirth (6-15%) and secondary infertility (11%). All in all it doesn’t paint a great picture of life after childbirth for some women. If any of your workers experience these issues, either on or off shore, it could have a significant impact on areas of their working life and it’s something they may be reluctant to open up about. Even before childbirth, we may take it for granted that contraception is available, certainly in the developed world. But in developing countries where sexual violence is not uncommon, contraception is considered lifesaving due to the high level of unsafe abortions carried out. Around 13 million women (and girls) under 20 give birth annually and complications in the pregnancy and birth is a leading cause of death. Consequently abortion is an option, but this carries its own huge risks.
by Rachel Smith 25 June 2024
We just love speaking to and finding out more about the people who inspire us and we guarantee that this month’s blog will not disappoint! We first got in touch with Wendy Sullivan via LinkedIn and thought she seemed like a pretty awesome human. Wendy and her company, Maritime Medical Solutions in Australia, certainly share the same outlook as Red Square Medical. Fast forward a couple of years and we’re now collaborating on a project in Australia and the Pacific Islands. What we’ve learnt along the way is simply fascinating and Wendy has kindly agreed to share her story with us… Here is Wendy’s Guest Blog: I was born in Canada, grew up in Africa and now call Australia my home. I feel lucky to live in paradise where the weather allows us to be on the water year-round. I had to work hard to gain my Australian citizenship and I credit my work in the marine industry with giving me a pathway to stay in Australia permanently. It took years of hard work and uncertainty to gain my residency and is still one of the achievements I am most proud of. I started sailing in Canada and since emigrating to Australia gained my professional and commercial qualifications as a vessel master, marine engine driver, trainer and assessor. I also have a Diploma of Paramedical Science, ship masters medical qualifications, business administration and development and there is still so much more to come.
More posts
Share by: