Soft tissue injury or potential fracture??

So is it a soft tissue injury or potential fracture? A sprained ankle can be a tricky one to navigate. Check out our guide to assessing severity when onboard a ship.

In the medical world, we use a tool called the Ottowa Ankle Rules to decide whether an x-ray is needed for an ankle injury. The tool was developed to meet a need for a rapid and accurate way to assess severity and avoid unnecessary x-rays. Of course if there’s a bone sticking out, or some dodgy looking deformity, then your decision may be a quick one!

Ankle sprains are a common injury in the general population and certainly not uncommon onboard vessels of all kinds. According to NICE Guidelines, lateral ankle sprains are the most prevalent form of musculoskeletal injury in physically active populations and an Australian study found that up to 70% of people reported having an ankle injury during their lifetime. Other studies indicate a higher incidence in females compared to males and that the risk is greater the younger you are. 

Historically, ankle injuries are seen frequently in emergency departments, but only 15% have significant fractures. The Ottowa Ankle Rules were developed as a tool for identifying ankle and mid-foot fractures. Less than 1.7% of patients presenting with no symptoms are likely to be suffering a fracture. This figure reduces the sooner after the injury that the assessment can be made. 

So how do the Ottowa Ankle Rules work and is it possible for an onboard medic to use them? Let’s start with a diagram…

This diagram shows the key areas of the foot and ankle that the rules apply to. Don’t worry about the big words, we’ll keep it simple! This short video might help too:

There are 5 components to test to assess whether your patient is positive for the Ottowa Ankle Rules. Always make sure you palpate areas thoroughly.


  1. Find the lateral (outside) malleolus at points A or B. Is there bony tenderness on palpation of 6 cm above the tip of the lateral malleolus? 
  2. Find the medial (inside) malleolus at points A or B. Is there bony tenderness on palpation of the 6 cm above the tip of the medial malleolus?
  3. Is there bony tenderness at the base of the 5th metatarsal?
  4. Is there bony tenderness at the navicular bone?
  5. Was the patient unable to bear weight immediately after the injury and for 4 steps during your assessment?


If there is pain in the malleolar zone, or the mid foot zone, or if the patient ticks the box for any of the above points, an ankle and/or foot x-ray is indicated.


Certain patient groups are excluded, for instance someone who happens to be intoxicated, if there is another reason that they lack ability to follow the test, or if the patient is pregnant. 


If you, or in conjunction with your Telemedicine provider, decide that your patient does need an x-ray, you will need to follow your vessel procedures for disembarkation or medevac, depending on your circumstances and location. 


But how would you treat an ankle injury if a fracture isn’t suspected?


On medical courses over the years, you’re likely to have come across mnemonics such as RICE, PRICE and POLICE in relation to the management of acute soft tissue injuries. We’ve listed them in full at the end of the blog for information.

But hey, we’re now moving on to
PEACE and LOVE! Far out man!


The aim of PEACE and LOVE, is to optimise recovery and healing as part of the soft tissue injury management from the first point of care.  It takes into consideration some important factors to aid recovery, but also highlights the potentially harmful effects of using anti-inflammatory medication as part of the process. Wowsa! So does this mean that taking anti-inflammatories isn’t the right thing to do any more? Let’s look into this PEACE and LOVE a bit more…


P - PROTECT

  • Unload or restrict movement for the first 1-3 days.
  • This reduces bleeding.
  • It prevents distension of any injured fibres.
  • It reduces the risk of aggravating the injury.
  • Minimise rest - prolonged rest actually compromises the tissue strength and quality.
  • Let the patient's level of pain guide the removal of protection and gradual reloading. 


E - ELEVATE

  • Elevate the injured limb higher than the heart. This helps to keep interstitial (in the spaces between the cells) fluid flowing out of the injured tissue. Although the evidence of its benefit is poor, there’s a low risk to benefit ratio and it may help some patients. 


A - AVOID ANTI-INFLAMMATORY MODALITIES (medications and treatments)

  • Anti-inflammatory medications may negatively impact long term healing, so don’t use them! This is because the inflammatory process actually supports optimal soft tissue regeneration. Using medications to inhibit this process can impair the healing process.
  • Avoid ice. The benefit of ice is mainly for pain relief and although it's used widely, there’s little high quality evidence to support its use in healing soft tissue injuries. Ice could also disrupt inflammation, the restoration of blood flow to the injured area and formation of new blood vessels. It can delay the infiltration of neutrophils and macrophages to fight infection, and potentially increase immature microfibres, resulting in impaired tissue regeneration.


C - COMPRESS

  • Joint swelling and internal bleeding may be limited by external compression such as taping or bandaging. But, it must allow full range of movement at the joint.


E - EDUCATE

  • Contrary to popular belief, there are many benefits to an active rather than passive approach to recovery.
  • Many passive therapies (e.g. electrotherapy, manual therapy, acupuncture) have minimal effects on pain and function compared to an active approach.
  • Load management will avoid over treatment. Over treatment can increase the likelihood of injections and surgery.
  • Dependence on therapies such as physiotherapy can actually contribute to persistent symptoms.
  • Set realistic expectations about recovery times. 


L - LOAD

  • Evidence shows that an active approach with movement and exercises is beneficial, so normal activities should start as soon as symptoms allow.
  • To provide optimal loading without increasing pain is indicated. It promotes repair and builds tissue tolerance and the capacity of tendons, muscles and ligaments.


O - OPTIMISM

  • Our brains can play a significant role in rehabilitation interventions. Research shows that these factors may explain differences in symptoms and limitations better than the degree of injury.
  • Barriers to recovery include many psychological factors, such as catastrophisation, depression and fear. 
  • Pessimistic patient expectations can negatively influence the outcomes and prognosis of an injury.
  • It’s important to stay realistic and encourage optimism to improve chances of optimal recovery.


V - VASCULARISATION

  • Cardiovascular physical activity is needed to manage musculoskeletal injuries.
  • While more research is needed, evidence suggests that pain free cardiovascular activity increases blood flow to injuries and is a motivation booster. 
  • Benefits of early mobilisation and aerobic exercise improves function and work status and reduces the need for pain relief.


E - EXERCISE

  • Evidence shows that exercise therapy can reduce the risk of a recurring injury.
  • Exercise can restore mobility, strength and proprioception (sense of self-movement, force and body position) after an injury.
  • Avoiding pain can help to promote optimal repair initially, and pain can be used as a guide to progress the difficulty of exercises gradually.


This short film might help to explain it too:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HGTabgG7GIU&t=1s


So what does PEACE and LOVE mean onboard. Nope, it’s not a cue to smoke weed and hug each other while wearing flowers in our hair!


What it does mean is that crew with ankle injuries where a fracture isn’t suspected, can take pain relief (but not anti-inflammatories), use compression and elevation initially and keep the joint moving gently. As the pain allows, they should be encouraged to start to weight bear and exercise the joint. 


Of course if you’re managing a crew member with a musculoskeletal injury and you aren’t sure what to do, please remember to contact your telemedicine provider.



Previous mnemonics used in the treatment of soft tissue injuries:

RICE - Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation.

PRICE - Protect, Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation.

POLICE - Protection, Optimal Loading, Rest, Ice, Compression, Elevation.


Resources used for this blog:


https://cks.nice.org.uk/topics/sprains-strains/background-information/prevalence/

https://www.physio-pedia.com/Peace_and_Love_Principle

https://www.physio-pedia.com/Ottawa_Ankle_Rules

We love this blog, it is so informative.....why not share the peace and love.....


by Rachel Smith 12 February 2025
In this month's blog, as aching hearts aren’t just related to Valentines Day, we’re taking a look at chest pain! Chest pain is a common reason for calls for an ambulance or to shoreside, and frequently it’s not actually due to cardiac (heart) issues. But you will often hear Paramedics tell their patients that they have done the right thing; they would genuinely prefer to get to a patient and find the chest pain is a minor issue, than it being cardiac, and too late! Last year, we wrote this blog about 20 causes of chest pain (plus a bonus one!). Some of the conditions described are acute (sudden onset), some are chronic (long term), some need urgent attention, others not so much. But we should always take chest pain seriously and make sure a full assessment is done at the earliest opportunity to rule out anything life threatening. Typical symptoms of cardiac chest pain and/or a heart attack are:
by Rachel Smith 29 January 2025
Get ready for something super exciting! After a full year of intense planning and meticulous preparation, we're thrilled to announce the launch of our all-encompassing medical support service — FleetMed Support! Customised Maritime Medical Solutions Whether you have a fleet of ships or a single vessel, managing medical operations can be daunting without dedicated support. This makes FleetMed Support a perfect solution for the cruise, expedition and superyacht sectors. Our approach is simple: We take the burden of medical management off your shoulders, allowing you to focus on the bigger picture. With 24/7 support, we create a customized service level agreement for your fleet, ensuring that every detail is taken care of. So what’s new and why haven’t we done this before? Well, we're not a company that rushes into things. Instead, we take the time to thoroughly research and understand what's needed, ensuring we can deliver to the very high standards we set for ourselves and maintain those standards at all costs. Let's be honest, it's the continuous pursuit of excellence, the commitment to always improve, and the understanding that there's always more to learn that drives us forward each day. This means we are now ready to launch what we believe is a truly great portfolio of customisable services. So, how could this look for your company? Working with us is straightforward and hassle-free. We start by listening carefully to your specific requirements so that we can thoroughly understand your needs, and discuss your current gaps. Once we have a clear picture, we craft a tailored plan to deliver the precise services you require. Our process is marked by clear and concise communication at every step. We believe in total transparency, ensuring that you are kept in the loop throughout the entire process. We pride ourselves on our efficiency and dedication. Once the plan is in place, our experienced team gets to work, executing the agreed-upon services with precision and care. Our goal is to deliver exceptional results without any drama, making your experience as smooth and stress-free as possible.
by Rachel Smith 15 January 2025
From Flu jabs to far flung destinations… Vaccinations are a hotly debated topic across the globe, particularly after COVID-19 and the rapid response to the need for a vaccination to help reduce the burden on the health services in different countries. While the majority of healthcare workers and the general population support the ‘prevention is better than cure’ line of thinking, and therefore vaccinations, there are others who are determinedly against vaccinations for any disease, whatever the risk of mortality and death may be. In the UK, the BCG (Bacillus Calmette-Guerin) vaccination used to be given to all children in their teenage years to protect against tuberculosis. The vaccine has been so successful that TB is virtually eradicated now, and the majority of cases are due to migration. Now it’s only given to those deemed at high risk - babies and children at high risk, those travelling to high risk regions and adults coming into the UK from high risk countries. Depending on your country of origin, you should receive a range of vaccinations as a child or young adult. This will most likely include diphtheria, tetanus, polio and whooping cough, hepatitis and HIB (Influenza type B). Then MMR (measles, mumps and rubella), the pneumococcal vaccine (meningitis, pneumonia and sepsis) and HPV (Human Papilloma Virus) with a variety of boosters along the way. At the other end of the scale, the over 65s can receive vaccines for shingles, pneumococcal vaccine and respiratory syncytial virus along with flu and covid vaccines.
by Rachel Smith 30 December 2024
Reflection is an essential part of medicine and our regular followers will know that every year, we like to take a look back and assess where we started and how far we’ve come over the last 12 months. So, please join us on our whirlwind recap of 2024 as we get ready for a fabulous 2025… In 2024 we increased the number of STCW training clients to 4 organisations in 6 locations. We delivered STCW training at all levels to over 250 students. We delivered bespoke training to over 75 students onboard Superyachts and cruise ships. We delivered first aid at work or oxygen training to over 40 students, on land and on ships.
by Rachel Smith 18 December 2024
Welcome to our December blog, which is all about the recovery position and how to manage an unconscious casualty who is breathing normally. Unconsciousness is a medical emergency as the person is very vulnerable and may not be able to manage their own airway effectively. We also need to think about the cause of unconsciousness. Is it a simple fainting episode due to illness? Is it a massive hemorrhage causing hypovolemic shock? Or is it due to some kind of external factor or injury? This blog looks at how to manage an unconscious casualty. So, if we have a casualty who is unconscious, but who is breathing normally for themselves, and we’re not suspecting a serious injury, the recovery position is the best position to use while monitoring them. The recovery position keeps their airway open and makes sure that vomit or liquid won’t cause them to choke.
by Rachel Smith 11 December 2024
All the guest blogs! When we started adding blogs to our website back in early 2021, we did a little feature on each of our instructors of the time. They’re quite a fascinating bunch and the series proved quite popular amongst our followers. In addition to our amazing instructors, we work with some utterly incredible human beings all over the world, and the idea of sharing their stories grew and developed into what eventually became a monthly guest blog. It’s been interesting to find out more about how medical care at sea or in remote locations features in their work, and to discover a few fun facts along the way. This month, we thought that it might be a fun idea to give you a chance to go back into the archives and review all the guest blogs over the last few years! Maybe even let us know which your favourite one is?
by Rachel Smith 27 November 2024
We’ve taken a look at the 2023 Casualty Summary Report from the Maritime Authority of the Cayman Islands (MACI) to see what kind of incidents and trends their data shows us, even with relatively small data sets, and how this may be able to transfer to our own risk assessments and actual practice. You can find the report here: Cayman Maritime Report 2023 The first thing we noted was the authors note that the data is split out into incidents. This means that one incident may include a number of events. So a collision and any resulting injury is one incident, but is reported as two events, or more, if more than one person is injured. It made us wonder whether this method of reporting by an authority represents how incidents are reported onboard and whether it should be a consideration? Of course, for any set of statistics presented at the moment, we also have to consider the COVID-19 pandemic and the impact this has on trends including that period. While essential shipping continued, the cruise and superyacht sectors reduced activity and staffing, often to a skeleton crew while anchored somewhere. So this will be reflected in the historic data sets that we analyse from 2019 to 2021 and may not accurately reflect increases and decreases during and since then. In some situations, we may need to look further back for accurate data. We also need to consider whether increases in incidents and events is also down to increased reporting - suggesting an improvement in the awareness of reporting requirements and greater engagement from the industry and individual sectors - this can only be a good development. Since 2020, the type of injury has been recorded in 8 different categories, with hand and foot injuries topping the leaderboard, closely followed by head, body, and back injuries. So if you were looking to run drills, or practise medical skills, these would be the key areas to cover. Only one death was an occupational accident, and is being investigated here: MAIB Investigations (search for case #9229607). It relates to a fall down a ventilation shaft on a bulk carrier in a Greek shipyard. The full report was still pending at the time of writing. Merchant ships are heavily regulated by a number of authorities, and the requirements for personal protective equipment and safe systems of work are enforced and applied to reduce accidents and incidents onboard. This has led to a lower reporting of incidents than in the commercial yacht sector. Could there be room for improvement here in this area? We certainly think so. Many of the hand and foot injuries reported can be career ending or life changing, but are preventable. Follow up has shown that there is a link here with injuries being sustained when inappropriate or no PPE was used. The supply and use of appropriate PPE is mandatory on vessels subject to the MLC and it’s worth remembering that some PPE can be produced in styles and designs compatible with the aesthetics of a yacht if required! On a much wider scale, a lack of transparency and standardisation globally can affect the collection of data and the issue of under reporting. While the MACI figures may be accurate, we need other accurate figures to compare them to, in order to build a bigger picture across the world as we have in aviation. From December 2024, the Maritime Labour Convention (MLC) will be enforcing an amendment so that seafarer deaths will be recorded and reported annually. The MACI and Cayman Islands Shipping Registry produces a number of safety flyers that are publicly available HERE that may be useful. In summary, analysing data can sometimes result in more questions than answers. But even this can lead to interesting and important developments that result in improved safety and reduced incidents and accidents onboard. Key points to take from this report are: Use the correct PPE for the task. Employ approved systems of work and risk assessments for the task. Reporting is key for safety in the future of our industry. Enjoy a night ashore, but don’t over do the cocktails! As always, if you’d like any input on medical training onboard or ashore, or drills that you can run yourselves, please just get in touch. References: https://www.lloydslist.com/LL1145359/Increase-in-incidents-of-deaths-at-sea
by Rachel Smith 6 November 2024
Welcome to our latest guest blog where we’ve been chatting to James Griffiths, General Manager of Ocean Operations for Scenic Group and finding out more about what happens behind the scenes in order to keep a fleet of luxury expedition ships running. Here’s what James told us… As General Manager of Ocean Operations, I’m responsible for the operations of our fleet which includes four ships in service with around 850 colleagues. I currently live in Mumbles, near Swansea in the UK, but due to the nature of my work I spend a significant amount of time living in Croatia. Prior to this role, I spent many years working at sea and worked up through the ranks to Captain and over the last 15 years, my main focus has been on polar expedition travel. I hold a master mariner certificate of competency in addition to a degree in engineering and a post graduate diploma in law. Part of my job is to work with our medical service provider (Red Square Medical) to ensure that our ships are offering medical services that are appropriate for their deployment, and this can often be to some of the most extreme and remote locations around the world. It’s extremely varied, though during the COVID-19 pandemic, I came ashore when our operations paused for a significant period of time. I was fortunate enough to be given the opportunity to lead the restart of our Ocean Operations, which included setting up everything from a company to manage the ships, to selecting our crewing, medical, helicopter and submarine partners and providers, amongst many other things. Our areas of operation, and the nature of our cruises (expedition), plus having aircraft and submersibles onboard some, do mean additional elements involved in the management of these ships. You could say that this current position is more of a happy coincidence than one that I actually planned for! In some ways this is a great positive - I do think it’s possible to plan a little too much and then be disappointed if things don’t go quite the way you had imagined. But there’s no danger of that here!
by Rachel Smith 3 October 2024
Back in February 2022, we brought you one of our very first guest blogs from Simon Lawton, a Paramedic who has swapped out his ambulance for a Superyacht! You can read the original blog here: https://www.redsquaremedical.com/superyacht-paramedic-a-guest-blog-from-simon-lawton Over the last 2+ years, we’ve followed Simon’s career, and some of you may even recognise him as he does put a Red Square Medical instructor hat on from time to time. But, as for all healthcare professionals, Simon has to keep his skills up to date. So, we asked him to tell us a bit more about how he juggles this along with a rota onboard. Here’s what he told us… I’m originally from Stoke-on-Trent in the UK and trained as a HCPC registered Paramedic. I’ve spent almost 5 years working at sea now, with almost continuous employment on three different vessels, after leaving the ambulance service in 2019. My first role was as a Paramedic/Deck hand on Superyachts, and I now work as a Medical Officer on a maritime vessel. Even before I applied to become a Paramedic, I intended to complete my studies to help find employment in a remote or offshore environment. I had always been attracted to the idea of being able to travel the world while earning a salary. Working at sea has meant that I have travelled extensively, earnt a higher salary, and have a better work/rest balance than would be possible in a role on land. Note: At the time of writing, a qualified Paramedic’s starting pay in the UK was £28,407 and Simon’s old rota was 2 days, 2 nights (all 12 hours) and 4 days off with very inflexible annual leave. This year I decided to carry out some continual professional development (CPD) at a hospital in Mexico, to keep my skills up to date. I was interested in travelling to find out more about how healthcare services are provided outside the UK and Europe. The CPD activity in Mexico allowed me to do exactly that, while caring for and treating a wide variety of patients who had either self-presented in the emergency department, or been conveyed to hospital by ambulance.
by Rachel Smith 25 September 2024
Welcome to our September blog, and as we all start (in the UK at least!) to think about adding a few layers for warmth, we’d like to talk about getting naked! Well, to be more specific, getting bra’s off. Fact: Women are dying because bystanders are less likely to carry out CPR on women than men. Research shows that women are 27% less likely to receive CPR than men and if a defibrillator is used, their chance of survival is affected by bra’s being left on. Most of us have never had the chance to train using a female manikin. The #BraOffDefibOn campaign aims to address the inequality in CPR for women and we’re supporting it.
More posts
Share by: